 |
| Switch 2 next to PC monitor with PlayStation logo |
In an era where blockbuster games like Call of Duty and Fortnite dominate every screen, the strategy of console exclusivity seems like a relic. With publishers chasing the widest possible audience, why would any company limit a game to just one platform? According to a former PlayStation chief, the answer is brand identity, hardware innovation, and old-fashioned fan loyalty.
Shawn Layden, former Chairman of Sony Interactive Entertainment Worldwide Studios, recently sat down for a revealing interview on the Pause for Thought podcast. His message was clear: while the industry trends toward "play anywhere," the exclusive game still holds immense power.
"I don't think every game should be console-exclusive," Layden stated, acknowledging the shifting landscape. "But as long as we have platforms, there is huge value to the brand in having strong exclusives."
The Power of "Only On": Building Brand Legends
Layden pointed to gaming's most iconic figures as proof of concept. Nintendo’s Mario is inseparable from its consoles, driving generations of hardware sales. Similarly, PlayStation built a empire with characters like Nathan Drake from Uncharted and Kratos from God of War.
"These franchises become synonymous with the experience of that platform," Layden explained. "For many gamers, the decision to buy a PlayStation or a Nintendo Switch is fundamentally a decision to play with those characters." This emotional connection, he argues, is a business advantage no amount of cross-platform revenue can easily replace.
More Than a Port: When a Game Is Designed for the Hardware
The argument goes beyond marketing. Layden highlighted how modern exclusives are often built to showcase a system's unique capabilities. PlayStation 5’s Astro Bot was meticulously crafted as a showcase for the haptic feedback and adaptive triggers of the DualSense controller—a experience that simply doesn't translate to a standard Xbox pad or PC setup.
On the other side, Nintendo constantly innovates with its hybrid hardware. The use of Joy-Cons for motion-controlled or local multiplayer gameplay is a hallmark of its first-party titles. If a game like The Legend of Zelda or Super Mario Odyssey were designed for a generic controller, something integral would be lost.
"You can port the game," Layden suggests, "but you can't always port the magic. The unique appeal of the hardware is part of the game's DNA."
For a deeper dive into Layden's perspective on platform identity and the future of consoles, check out his full conversation on the Pause for Thought podcast.
The Cross-Platform Counter-Reality
Layden is no idealist; he readily admits that exclusivity isn't a one-size-fits-all model. He sees little logic in restricting massive multiplayer and live-service games to one console. This aligns with Sony’s current, more open strategy, which has seen successful titles like Helldivers 2 launch day-one on PlayStation and PC, with an Xbox version following.
The pattern for major narrative-driven games, however, remains. Upcoming titles like Ghost of Yotei are confirmed as PlayStation 5 exclusives, at least initially. The PC has become a consistent, but delayed, secondary platform—a compromise that builds console buzz before tapping into a second massive market.
The Uncertain Future: One Device to Rule Them All?
Despite his defense of exclusives, Layden recognizes the powerful consumer dream of a single device that can play everything. He nods to Microsoft’s strategy of treating Windows PC as the ultimate Xbox hardware, and recalls ambitious, if flawed, projects like Valve’s Steam Machine that aimed to bridge the PC and living room.
The skeptic's view is that console and PC audiences are still largely distinct. Consoles thrive on simplicity and consistency—a sealed system where games "just work." For exclusives to truly fade, a company must first perfectly merge the plug-and-play comfort of a console with the open library and power of a PC.
For now, the giants are playing both sides. They are expanding their reach with selective PC ports and live-service cross-play games while fiercely guarding their most iconic single-player experiences. As Layden’s insights reveal, the exclusive game isn't dying—it's just becoming a more strategic, calculated weapon in the console wars. The battle for your living room is still being fought, one "Only On" tagline at a time.