 |
| Garmin Connect does not always reliably recognize food in initial tests. |
Fitness tech giant Garmin has stepped decisively into the dietary arena, announcing a new AI-powered Nutrition Tracking feature for its Garmin Connect+ subscribers. Promising a seamless fusion of diet, sleep, and workout data, the tool aims to be a holistic health companion. But as early adopters and expert reviewers are discovering, the path from plate to actionable insight is still a bit bumpy.
The Promise: Scan, Track, Understand
Unveiled this week, the feature is designed to simplify the often-tedious process of food logging. Subscribers to the paid Garmin Connect+ service can now use their smartphone to scan a product’s barcode or, more impressively, simply point their camera at a meal. Artificial intelligence is tasked with identifying the food, logging it, and integrating this data into the broader Garmin ecosystem.
The grand vision is powerful. As detailed in Garmin’s official announcement, the system doesn’t just count calories. It evaluates nutrient trends over time and aims to analyze the impact of different foods and diets on your workouts, recovery, and sleep patterns. Users set a target weight, and Garmin calculates a daily calorie goal, broken down across meals and snacks.
The Reality: A Dash of Friction, a Pinch of Inaccuracy
However, initial hands-on reviews suggest the technology isn’t quite ready to replace your kitchen scale—or your patience. Respected fitness tech reviewers DC Rainmaker and The5kRunner have put the feature through its paces, uncovering significant limitations that potential users should consider.
First, there’s a notable setup hurdle. As highlighted in The5kRunner’s detailed review, anyone who previously synced their MyFitnessPal account—a popular method for Garmin users—must disconnect it to use the native Garmin nutrition tool. This creates an immediate barrier for an engaged core user base.
The much-touted AI camera scanning receives mixed grades. While it adeptly identifies simple, whole foods like a single banana, it struggles with composite meals. A plate with three slices of toast might be logged as one. Toppings like butter or jam are often missed entirely, throwing off macro calculations. The AI also reportedly has trouble distinguishing between similar items, such as white and whole-grain bread.
Perhaps the biggest practical issue is portion sizing. The app frequently defaults to a 100-gram serving size, making a digital food scale essential for accuracy. For items like peanut butter, sauces, or cereal, estimating without a scale leads to highly unreliable data, as Garmin’s defaults may not align with real-world serving habits.
 |
| Many features of Garmin's nutrition tracking are only available on the smartphone, not on the smartwatch. |
Watch Limitations and Bugs
The experience on Garmin’s famed smartwatches is currently limited. While you can view your day’s calorie and nutrient intake, logging new foods is restrictive. You can only add meals you’ve pre-saved in the app; spontaneous snacks or restaurant meals require your phone. Furthermore, DC Rainmaker notes in his video analysis that the watch app has been prone to regular crashes, hindering usability.
The Verdict: A Strong Foundation Needing Refinement
Garmin’s foray into nutrition tracking is a logical and ambitious step toward total health management. The potential to correlate dietary patterns with performance and recovery metrics is a compelling proposition for data-driven athletes.
Yet, in its initial iteration, the feature feels like a beta release. The accuracy gaps in scanning, the cumbersome need for constant weighing, and the limited watch functionality mean it demands significant user effort for reliable results. For those seeking a truly passive or highly precise tracking experience, sticking with dedicated nutrition apps for now may be wiser.
The framework is there, and Garmin’s history of iterative improvement is strong. But for the moment, their new Nutrition Tracking serves as a reminder that even the smartest AI still has a lot to learn about the wonderfully messy world of what we eat.