Zelda: Ocarina of Time User Score Drops as GTA 6 Review Bombing Escalates

0

 

Banner for GTA 6 and Zelda: Ocarina of Time Metacritic review bombing shown

The rivalry between Grand Theft Auto VI and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time has taken an unexpected turn on Metacritic. Following a wave of negative user ratings targeting GTA 6, the 2026 Zelda remake has reportedly experienced a similar backlash, with its user score falling from 9.6 to 8.7 out of 10.

The situation has sparked a debate about coordinated review bombing and the reliability of user-generated ratings. A separate Reddit investigation examining nearly 14,000 Metacritic accounts also reveals unusual voting patterns, suggesting that some users may be rating one game negatively while awarding its perceived rival a near-perfect score.

Zelda: Ocarina of Time Faces a Sudden Metacritic Rating Drop

The Nintendo Switch 2 remake of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time had maintained a strong user rating after Metacritic opened community reviews on November 6, 2026. However, a sudden influx of zero-score reviews reportedly pushed its average down from 9.6 to 8.7 within approximately 24 hours.

The backlash follows a controversial reception for Grand Theft Auto VI on Metacritic, where the game reportedly received a user score of just 5.6 despite earning a 99 Metascore from professional critics. That sharp difference between critic and player ratings has intensified arguments between supporters of Rockstar Games and Nintendo.

Some negative Zelda reviews reportedly reference GTA 6 directly rather than discussing Zelda's gameplay, visuals, or other features. This raises concerns that at least part of the backlash is motivated by rivalry between fan communities rather than genuine dissatisfaction with the game. Readers can follow the changing figures on the Zelda: Ocarina of Time Metacritic page.

GTA 6 Metacritic user score shown

Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake Metacritic user score shown

Reddit Analysis Examines Nearly 14,000 Negative Reviewers

An independent investigation shared by Reddit user gtrhawk provides additional context. The researcher examined 13,990 Metacritic profiles associated with negative written reviews of GTA 6 or the Zelda remake, analyzing whether those accounts had also rated the competing game.

The initial findings revealed a striking difference between the two groups:

  • 63% of negative Zelda reviewers gave GTA 6 a positive score between 8 and 10.
  • 15.9% of negative GTA 6 reviewers awarded Zelda a score between 8 and 10.
  • 83.8% of negative GTA 6 reviewers had no visible review of the Zelda remake.
  • 33.5% of negative Zelda reviewers had no visible review of GTA 6.

The analysis also found that Zelda received 110 accessible negative written reviews between November 6 and November 19, followed by another 752 on November 20 and 21. Approximately two-thirds of the latter group came from accounts that had rated GTA 6 positively.

These figures come from the researcher's Reddit analysis of Metacritic review profiles, rather than an official Metacritic investigation. The researcher later updated the dataset to include the original 1998 Ocarina of Time, reporting that it was also experiencing a surge in negative reviews.

Why the Numbers Do Not Prove Coordinated Review Bombing

Although the voting patterns suggest that competition between the two fanbases may be influencing user ratings, they do not establish who organized the activity or whether every negative review was submitted in bad faith. The investigation covered accessible written reviews, not every rating included in Metacritic's overall user scores. Some ratings have no accompanying public review, while moderation and data-access limitations can affect the results.

Metacritic user ratings also differ from verified-purchase reviews on digital storefronts. Users do not generally need to demonstrate that they own a game before submitting a score, making public rating systems more vulnerable to organized campaigns. However, a negative score alone is not evidence of manipulation, and legitimate criticism can coexist with review bombing.

GTA 6 and Zelda Highlight the Limits of User Scores

The controversy is particularly noteworthy because both franchises have established reputations for critical acclaim. GTA 6 reportedly debuted with a 99 Metascore, matching the historic score achieved by the original 1998 release of Ocarina of Time. GSMGoTech previously covered GTA 6's initial 99 Metacritic rating and its comparison with Zelda.

The contrast becomes even more interesting when considering other platforms. In a separate report, GSMGoTech examined GTA 6 surpassing 200,000 PlayStation Store ratings, where its early average remained considerably more positive. The difference illustrates how ratings can vary depending on the platform, audience, and review requirements.

For players deciding whether to purchase either game, professional reviews, detailed user feedback, gameplay footage, and platform-specific performance information provide a more complete picture than a single numerical score. With both Metacritic user ratings subject to further changes, the current averages should be treated as snapshots rather than definitive assessments of either title's quality.

I checked the Metacritic profiles of ~14000 people who left a negative user review on GTA VI or the Ocarina of Time remake. Here's how they rated the other game
by u/gtrhawk in videogames

Sources: Metacritic – Zelda: Ocarina of Time, Metacritic – Grand Theft Auto VI, Reddit – User Rating Analysis.

Tags:

Post a Comment

0 Comments

Post a Comment (0)